Dec 31 2008
Black tie optional
Pre-Ramble: So, you get an invitation to an event and at the bottom below the RSVP in a tiny font is a line that says “Black tie optional” … What the heck does that mean? Like “business casual,” these three words can strike fear into even the most hip of dressers. (The fact that I just used the word “hip” automatically disqualifies me from being that.)
If you’re an undertaker, James Bond, or hosting the Academy Awards, the black tie directive is pretty clear. Same goes for most wedding parties. In all other situations, the optional black tie designation is dicey. In this form of fashion Russian Roulette, chances are good that half the crowd will be over-dressed and half the crowd will be under-dressed. Those folks who claim that it is better to be over-dressed than under-dressed never went to my cousin’s house for Thanksgiving. Every year we would show up in some form of holiday casual wear which, when you’re ten and it’s 1967, means a corduroy jumper, turtleneck, cable-knit tights and shoes with buckles. We would walk through that front door and every kid in the house had changed out of their “church clothes” hours ago and was rolling around on the floor in sweat pants and a t-shirt.
According to wikipedia, a source widely known as an authority on fashion, an appropriate black tie ensemble can vary. In brief, the traditional components are:
- a short coat with silk facings (usually grosgrain or satin), also called the dinner jacket
- trousers with silk braids matching the lapels
- a black cummerbund or low-cut waistcoat
- a white dress shirt with either a stiff or pleated front
- black dress socks
- black shoes in patent or highly polished leather
Far beyond the confines of the requisite monkey suit, contemporary black tie outfits can incorporate many interesting variations including color-coordinated cummerbunds and ties, different colors and/or collars on shirts, or even different types of cut and materials. Elton John once performed in a tuxedo made entirely of feathers.
If only it were that easy: Unfortunately, “black tie optional” is a thousand times more ominous for women. I’ll be the first one to jump at a chance to dress up for Halloween, but selecting appropriate formal wear is another matter entirely. The pitfall to dressing for special occasions is that there are so many ways that you can look wrong. Ellen DeGeneres is the only woman who can really pull off the “tuxedo look,” and the crisp-white-shirt-unbuttoned-down-to-there-with-black-pants-and-spike-heels option looks very sexy unless you’re sporting a pasty winter skin-tone and have little hope of rallying “the girls” into anything resembling cleavage. In a dress that’s too poufy, you look like you’re headed to the prom; too tight, you’re a hooker; in a more mature get-up, you’re mother-of-the-bride. Women have to consider length and neckline of dress, accessories, hair style, shoes, clutch and wrap; not to mention outdoor temperature, general terrain, duration of event, and whatever your escort will be wearing.
In her new book, The Little Black Book of Style, Nina Garcia, fashion editor at Elle Magazine and judge on the hit show Project Runway, suggests that,
“Every time you dress, you assert some aspect of yourself and your identity. With style, you tell the world who you are, or at least the story of who you would like to be on that particular day.”
Great. On this particular day in Minnesota it is nine degrees below zero - my polar fleece track suit and Uggs are telling the world that I don’t want to freeze my ass off in spaghetti straps or break an ankle careening around in some parking lot. Does Jimmy Choo have something in a strappy little snowshoe? I’m sure an ice ax won’t fit into my evening bag.
The Take-Away: Perhaps you can consider the “black tie optional” as another opportunity to step out of your comfort zone. Or, what the heck… wear whatever makes you feel fun, it’s usually dark anyway. Cheers to a happy, healthy and stylish New Year!
Post-note: Those of you living in the Arctic Circle who didn’t lose it all in the stock market might be interested in picking up one of these whimsical, uniquely-shaped evening bags fashioned from hand-glued Austrian crystals by designer, Judith Lieber. The bag features a push down snap closure and detachable chain strap (looks like a rat-tail in photo at right). Comes beautifully boxed with a keepsake bag - $3,995.
Pre-Ramble: Hi, it’s me Daisy… resident canine and guest blogger extraordinaire. So, tick, tock … ’tis the day before Christmas and Mom is in the other room frantically trying to wrap presents. I want to be supportive, but really, when that is going on, you just have to gather up the chew toys and head out of Dodge.

