
Pre-Ramble: According to a recent snippet on the Wall Street Journal’s sports page (?) Alex Rodriguez, the “much maligned” third baseman for the New York Yankees, took a pie-to-the-face at the hand of teammate A.J. Burnett during a postgame interview. The foamy high-jinx, captured on youtube, shows the pie grazing the right side of unsuspecting A-Rod’s face (photo of aftermath shown right) as he reflected on his two-run homer slammed at the bottom of the 11th inning to seal a Yankee victory over the Minnesota Twins (6-4).
Give that man a Q-tip! I’m sure there are a bunch of dugout dynamics that I (admittedly a fair-weather fan) am not privy to. Apparently, a pie in the face is some kind of celebratory baseball tradition … ? Who knew? Well, apple pie, maybe … and I don’t mean to be a poor sport here, but when did hitting someone in the face with a pie become an acceptable standard mode of communication — celebratory or otherwise?
While my girls were quick to offer help with some first-hand research, less sticky sources describe “pieing“ (yes, there is an actual verb for it) as the act of throwing a pie at a person. Fair enough. Variations on motivation and meaning around pieing:
This can be a political action when the target is an authority figure, politician, or celebrity, and can be used as a means of protesting against the target’s political beliefs, or against a perceived flaw in the target’s character (arrogance, hubris, etc.). Perpetrators generally regard the act as a form of ridicule to embarrass and humiliate the victim. (wikipedia)
Pieing had its origins in slapstick comedy in the early 1900’s, coming into its own as a comedy bit in the Laurel & Hardy classic short film, “The Battle of the Century,” where a legendary 4,000 pies were engaged. Other comedians and cartoon characters known for pieing include the Three Stooges, Bugs Bunny, Charlie Chaplin, Monty Python and Soupy Sales. The 1965 comedy,” The Great Race,” reportedly features the largest pie fight in cinematic history. (To be fair, some cakes were involved in that melee.)
Astonishingly, there are entire websites devoted to the art and science of pieing. Here, from a site called sjnetwork, are some general pieing pointers:
- whipped cream – works well, but can be troublesome to make in large quantities and has a tendency to melt; blending some sugar into the mixture gives the substance more body
- Cool Whip – melts quickly if used alone; mixed with sour cream or yogurt, it will maintain its shape for several hours
- aerosol whipped cream is “worse than useless,” melting/losing its shape in microseconds and leaving a film on the piee’s face that is very difficult to wash off
- shaving cream – doesn’t have the feel of real whipped cream, but “can be fun;” use the sensitive skin variety, which doesn’t sting the eyes; give it a creamier texture by mixing it with pancake batter …
- actual pies – pies purchased from a bakery “tend to be expensive and risky“ as they contain stabilizers which make them heavy and greatly inhibit the “splatter factor“
- A note on crusts – graham cracker is readily available and comes pre-formed in the pie tin, however tends to break up on impact; frozen crusts require thawing, forming and baking, but “make for better throwing and are well worth the extra effort“; using a paper-plate-as-quasi-crust is completely lacking in style and is just lame
Since the 1970’s, a broad collection of regular folks have been pied … more than one might imagine, including Anita Bryant, William F. Buckley, G. Gordon Liddy, E. Howard Hunt, William Shatner, Andy Warhol, filmmaker Jean-Luc Godard, Bernard-Henri Levy, conservative pundit Ann Coulter (while fundamentally opposed to pieing, I would have thrown that one), David Horowitz, Ralph Nadar, Fred Phelps, Jean Chretien (then-Prime Minister of Canada), Microsoft founder Bill Gates, and celebrated economist Thomas Friedman.
Call me a stick-in-the-mud, but I am just not a fan of this whole ”punked,” ”pranked,” food-fight, “let’s trash this” mentality. Maybe it’s because I’m usually on the clean-up end of these events, but I just don’t see where it’s so funny. And it goes beyond that. It’s about consent. Throwing a pie in someone’s face outside of a situation where the likelihood of the act is known and agreed upon in advance, is not only not funny, it’s a physically aggressive thing.
In the movies — it’s written into the script as a comic device; and, I would venture to say that many actors would rather take a pie to the face than have to speak aloud some of the truly inane lines that are assigned to their character. … Among frat-boys and baseball players — sure, whatever; there is probably a whipped cream clause in fine print at the bottom of A-Rod’s $275 million contract. … Paintball, laser tag, and that community fair favorite, the dunk tank, are all cases of implied consent (the guy who crawls onto the platform and dangles his feet over the vat of disgusting green water knows full well what is coming). … In cases where a person is clearly smug, pompous, or otherwise full of themselves, that fact is usually more than obvious and self-incriminating. In a situation where a regular person is exercising their right to free speech however, a pie-in-the-face is mean-spirited and demeaning — and it’s a physical assault.
The Take-Away: Flying whipped cream is not protected under the First Amendment. If you want to stand up and yell, “Pie in your face!!” that would be unfortunate and disruptive, but it wouldn’t cross the line into unacceptable behavior that is punishable by law. The minute that pie leaves your hand, it’s a whole new ball game.
On a similar note, I would consider the grand scale food-fight which occurred in the American Idol mansion this season to be a disrespectful, wasteful and sad variation on the pie-in-the-face theme. Maybe we’d be singing a different tune if they had scraped the $6,000 worth of flour, sugar and egg off the floor, walls and each other and shipped it over to the starving children in Darfur for whom they were soliciting earlier in the show.